Data Storage Today

CIO Today Network Sites:   Top Tech News  |   CIO Today   |   Mobile Tech Today   |   Data Storage Today
News & Information for Data Storage Professionals
Brocade delivers
cloud-optimized networking solutions
to deploy, manage, and scale networks.

www.brocade.com
Saturday, May 25th 
Panasonic Toughbook® mobile computers
Home
Data Centers
Storage Solutions
Storage Networks
Data Storage Issues
Data Security
Enterprise I.T.
DST Press Releases
 
Free Newsletters
Top CIO News
 
Mobile Tech Today
 

Advertisement

Business Briefing

Jury Rejects Oracle Patent Claims Against Google

Jury Rejects Oracle Patent Claims Against Google
May 23, 2012 2:36PM

Bookmark and Share
The patent case centered on the Java programming language that became Oracle's property when it purchased Sun Microsystems. Oracle insisted that Google's open-source Android, now the most popular operating system in the global market, could not have been created without Java, with Google even hiring Java engineers.

Panasonic Toughbook® mobile computers are engineered to withstand drops, spills, dust and grime, and to perform in the harshest environments. Rugged reliability, low cost of ownership and accolades from reviewers are just a few of the reasons why Toughbook computers keep winning over the world's toughest users. Click here to learn more.

Google did not infringe on the patent rights of database giant Oracle in its creation of the Android Relevant Products/Services operating system, a San Francisco jury decided Wednesday, ending the long and bitter litigation between the two tech giants that began in 2010.

The jury foreman checked off "no (not proven)" eight times in answer to claims by Redwood Shores, Calif.,-based Oracle that Google infringes on two of its patents.

Earlier Verdict On Copyrights

Oracle, however, did win in an earlier phase of the trial, decided on May 7, when the jury sided with Oracle's separate claim that Google infringed on some copyrights, to a small degree. Judge William Alsup of U.S. District Court in Northern California will decide after a break for Memorial Day weekend whether any damages will be awarded in that claim. Oracle's original claim was for $6.1 billion in damages, but Alsup ordered that the estimate be revised, and in February Oracle revised the figure to $230 million. The original claim involved six patents.

The judge must also make a determination on whether copyright law applies to application program interfaces, which will affect whether damages can be awarded.

The case centered on the Java programming language that became Oracle's property when it purchased Sun Microsystems. Oracle insisted that the open-source Android, now the most popular operating system in both the domestic and global markets, could not have been created without Java, with Google even hiring engineers who worked on Java, while Google insisted it instead used a language called Apache Harmony.

The trial brought top executives of both companies to the stand, including Google CEO Larry Page and Oracle CEO Lawrence Ellison, and led to some interesting moments and revelations, such as when Judge Alsup read a memo that revealed Google's claim that it made no net income from Android in 2010.

In a statement published by The New York Times, Oracle spokeswoman Deborah Hellinger suggested the company will appeal.

"Oracle presented overwhelming evidence at trial that Google knew it would fragment and damage Java," she said. "We plan to continue to defend and uphold Java's core 'write once run anywhere' principle and ensure it is protected for the 9 million Java developers and the community that depend on Java compatibility."

Victory for Android Ecosystem

Google spokesman Jim Prosser sent us a statement saying, "Today's jury verdict that Android does not infringe Oracle's patents was a victory not just for Google but the entire Android ecosystem."

Notwithstanding the earlier verdict and potential appeal, technology analyst Charles King of Pund-IT sees Wednesday's verdict as a crushing blow to Oracle in the case.

"Not only did the jury fundamentally disagree with Oracle's claims but also appeared to repudiate the essential reasoning behind the company's pursuit of damages," King said. "That could impact other claims by Oracle but may also affect and perhaps discourage similar IP litigation in the future."

King added that the case proved that "even cases centering on highly complex technological issues can be successfully parsed and determined with willing, disciplined reasoning."

Based on your interest in this article, here's something that may be of interest to you also:

Recommended Reading: Search & Destroy: Why You Can't Trust Google Inc. Synopsis: This is the other side of the Google story. In Search & Destroy, Google expert Scott Cleland, shows that the world's most powerful company is not who it pretends to be. Google pretends to be a harmless lamb, but chose a full-size model of a Tyrannosaurus Rex as its mascot. Beware the T-Rex in sheep's clothing.

Tell Us What You Think
Comment:

Name:

Advertisement



 Business Briefing
1. Is Waze Worth a Billion in Bidding War?
2. 7 ways To Not 'Screw Up' Tumblr
3. HP Profit Falls, But Outlook Soars
4. Google Buys Into Wind-Power Drones
5. Hirai Mulls Loeb's Sony Sell-Off Idea


advertisement


 Most Popular Articles
1. Half of Companies To Mandate BYOD by 2017, Gartner Says
2. Best of Interop Award Winners Announced
3. Novell Filr Offers IT-Friendly Dropbox Alternative
4. Add Guardian to Hacked List; Twitter Sends Security Memo
5. HP and SAP Team To Advance HANA Database Technology


advertisement

Have an informed opinion on this story?
Send a Letter to the Editor.
We want to know what you think.
Send us your Feedback.

 Related Topics  Latest News & Special Reports

  Money Stirs Electronic Records Push
  HP PCs Aim for Flexibility, Mobility
  Twitter Hoping To Halt Hack Attacks
  Nvidia GPU Boosts Citrix XenDesktop
  Security Alert: New Trojan Attacking

 Technology Marketplace

BYOD & MDM
Forrester Research Inc., Report: BYOD from AT&T. Make everyone more efficient.
 
Cloud & Virtualization
Brocade technologies help enable the full benefits of virtualization.
Riverbed Stingray Traffic Manager on Amazon Web Services
 
Contact Centers
Unlock the potential in your people with Microsoft Dynamics
Unlock the potential in your people with Microsoft Dynamics
 
Customer Service
Unlock the potential in your people with Microsoft Dynamics
Unlock the potential in your people with Microsoft Dynamics
 
Data Security
Simpana® 10 software: an exponential leap forward
 
Data Storage
Brocade makes it easier to deploy, manage, and scale networks.
 
Enterprise Software
Simpana® 10 software: an exponential leap forward
 
Hardware
Rugged and reliable Panasonic Toughbook® mobile computers.
 
Laptops & Tablets
Rugged and reliable Panasonic Toughbook® mobile computers.
 
Mobile Gadgets
Rugged and reliable Panasonic Toughbook® mobile computers.
 
Network Security
Brocade makes it easier to deploy, manage, and scale networks.
 
Navigation
Data Storage Today
Home/Top News | Data Centers | Storage Solutions | Storage Networks | Data Storage Issues | Data Security | Enterprise I.T.
DST Press Releases
Also visit these Enterprise Technology Sites
Top Tech News | CIO Today | Mobile Tech Today | Data Storage Today

Services:
FreeNewsFeed | Free Newsletters | XML/RSS Feed

About CIO Today Network | How To Contact Us | Article Reprints | Services for PR Pros (In partnership with NewsFactor) | Top Tech Wire | How To Advertise

Privacy Policy | Terms of Service
© Copyright 2000-2013 Data Storage Today. All rights reserved. Article rating technology by Blogowogo. Member of Accuserve Ad Network.